August 1, 2006
Le Maîtres Proprietary Daphnis
Pierre Monteux (1875-1964), one of the most
remarkable conductors of his time (or any other, for that matter), was also a serious and
effective pedagogue; he established a school for conductors at Hancock, Maine, which, as
he planned, continues long after his death. He began the important part of his career as a
conductor for the ballet company of the famous impresario Serge Diaghilev, whose influence
was considerable in sustaining and expanding upon the phenomenal Franco-Russian
cross-pollination touched off by Berliozs visit to Russia in 1867. Serge
Koussevitzky, a Russian-born conductor based in Paris until he succeeded Monteux with the
Boston Symphony Orchestra in 1924, brought that cross-pollination to its symbolic crest by
providing Ravel with the commission to orchestrate Mussorgskys piano suite Pictures
at an Exhibition in 1922. Monteux began his connection with Diaghilev before
Koussevitzky arrived in Paris: in 1911 he presided over the premiere of Stravinskys Petrushka;
two years later he conducted the tumultuous one of the same composers Rite of
Spring and that of Debussys Jeux; in 1912 he introduced Ravels Daphnis
and Chloe. It is our good fortune that he lived long enough to record all these works
-- among many others -- under optimal conditions in stereo. He recorded some of his
favorite pieces -- symphonies of Brahms and Berlioz as well as The Rite of Spring -- as
many as four and even five times. Ravels masterwork he recorded only once in its
entirety (following an earlier 78rpm account of the first of the two concert suites Ravel
extracted from that score), but that one version, taped in April1959, remains even now
about as definitive as a recorded performance can be; it is understandable that Decca has
kept it in its active catalogue without interruption since its initial release on LP and
has just brought out a new compact disc edition.
Monteux was born exactly four weeks after Maurice Ravel. He
knew Ravel, adored his music, and understood it down to the ground. By the time he
recorded Daphnis and Chloe he had formed a close connection with the London
Symphony Orchestra, which was at its peak then, with the horn player Barry Tuckwell, the
clarinetist Gervase de Peyer and the violinist Neville Marriner among its section leaders,
and was perhaps the busiest of all orchestras in the recording studio. (Marriner, the
LSOs principal second at the time, became one of Monteuxs conducting pupils in
his school at Hancock.) The LSO, in fact, made Monteux its chief conductor in 1961, when
he was 86, and gave him a 25-year contract. His death three years later kept him from
fulfilling the full term of that contract, but he did make quite a few memorable
recordings with the orchestra, for both Decca and Philips, and none of these is more
valuable, both musically and historically, than his Daphnis, produced by the
legendary John Culshaw, with the orchestra joined by the Chorus of the Royal Opera House,
Covent Garden.
Its latest incarnation
[Decca 475 7525] is part of a series for which Decca has borrowed a name from its sister
company Deutsche Grammophon: "The Originals" (with the disc itself also
following DGs "Originals" in giving the appearance of a small LP, with the
old-style label surrounded by simulated grooves). While Ive seen no form of
explication from Universal, the material to which Decca is affixing this rubric appears to
be a continuation of the somewhat earlier reissue series the company called Decca Legends.
Once again we have 96/24 remastering from the original master tapes, representing an
improvement on the last previous CD edition only slightly less stunning than the overall
improvement over the LPs. Like its most recent predecessor edition [448 603-2, in
Deccas "Classic Sound" series], this CD comprises all the Ravel Monteux
recorded for Decca: the 51 minutes of Daphnis (conveniently laid out on 12 tracks)
are followed by the Rapsodie espagnole and the Pavane pour une Infante défunte,
taped at the end of 1961 by another legendary producer, Erik Smith (the son of
the conductor Hans Schmidt-Isserstedt). These same recordings of the two shorter pieces
have appeared also on a Philips CD of still more Monteux/LSO Ravel, recorded for the Dutch
company only a few months before the conductors death in 1964: La Valse, Boléro and
the extended ballet version of Mother Goose. No serious collector has ever
complained about this duplication, and the new presentation in "The Originals"
is a shade more quiveringly realistic than the "Classic Sound" edition, which is
to say, this CD presents all the Decca material -- the peerless Daphnis in
particular -- at its best ever.
Koussevitzky, by the way, who succeeded Monteux in Boston
and made history there during his 25-year tenure, never invited his illustrious
predecessor back as a guest. That snub was addressed grandly by Koussevitzkys
successor, Charles Münch, who invited Monteux every season, took him on the
orchestras European tour, and approved RCA Victors wishes to record le
Maître (as Monteux was known to his associates) with the BSO. Among the
Monteux/Boston recordings: the last three Tchaikovsky symphonies, Monteuxs stunning
final Petrushka (all these in stereo) and, in mono, the most vivid of his four
studio recordings of The Rite of Spring.
...Richard Freed
richardf@ultraaudio.com
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/54011/54011317b810cd411cd23cb67f3da314f19c24bd" alt="PART OF THE SOUNDSTAGE NETWORK -- www.soundstagenetwork.com"
All contents copyright Schneider Publishing Inc., all rights
reserved.
Any reproduction, without permission, is prohibited.
Ultra Audio is part of the SoundStage! Network.
A world of websites and publications for audio, video, music, and movie enthusiasts. |